My friend and boss BigWillyC often suggests I move to East Nashville if and when we actually decide to sell our house in Reno, NV and lay down permanent roots here.
Now don't get me wrong, I really enjoy Tennessee but I won't retire here, of that I'm almost certain. I've tasted paradise, having lived in the Sierra Nevada Mountains for 20+ years and come hell or high water, I'm returning to them at some point. I don't like the humidity, the red-hot summer nights, and I especially don't like the kind of violent crime that seems to infest this otherwise wonderful city.
I know, I know, I shouldn't badmouth my bread and butter. I feel like I've accomplished more here than I have in any other place I've ever lived, and I'm only just beginning to get rolling behind Park Center and Will Connelly's latest bitchin brainstrorm, the introduction of the Vulnerability Index to combat chronic homelessness in our most vulnerable residents. An approach, incidentally, that has the entire homeless services section of our town buzzing and lining up to join in.
Tennessee has its charm and beauty, no doubt about it, but I gotta tell ya, you folks live and die by the sword a lot here. And I'm not speaking without some experience to back me up; I've lived and "partied" in some seriously dangerous places; spent much time wandering through the streets of downtown Detroit, near Clark Park and the Bridge to Canada and hung out with the pcp fiends in Melvindale. Started smoking dope with the hardcore hippies in Philadelphia, PA and have wandered into crack houses and "shooting galleries" from Sacramento to LA.
In my days on the street I've seen people stabbed, shot, overdosed, beaten with chain belts, ripped off and left for dead. I've stumbled over gang hits in the orchards of the central valley of California and spent a summer with a radically violent wingnut who was later convicted of capping an undercover informant behind a road service facility in the middle of nowhere. I watched a man stick another with a large buck knife so hard that he left the man pinned to the wall. I've seen more violence than I care to recall and for my sanity's sake - and to help you keep your last meal down - I'll stop describing it.
When I went to prison for a couple of years for growing the evil weed, I got the full-on tour of California correctional facilities. I initially started out in reception at High Desert but after they discovered I knew a person well in the mail room, I was rolled up and sent to - oh joy - San Quentin. Because the traditional spot for new fish - West Block - was full to overflowing, I got the unbelievably amazing opportunity to spend some 61 days in the "10 and over club "- the Carson unit of San Quentin Prison - where the worst of the worst goes to play for the remainder of their lives.
Lucky me.
But I wasn't finished experiencing the finest of the California Graybar chain yet. After I completed my reception, I got to go to Johnnie Cash's old haunt, Folsom Prison, but fortunately someone at San Quentin realized that I was about as low-risk as they come so they rolled me up and sent me across the street to the nieghborhood community correctional facility, a "camp snoopy" for morons who can't seem to keep their noses clean.
I spent the next 8 months hanging out with the minor-league dregs of our nation's collective society until I was released and sent back home. Utterly ridiculous waste of your money, I assure you, but hey, the law's the law.
My point in sharing this most embarrassing and humiliating portion of my past is to reinforce upon you my experience with assholes of all shapes and sizes. I've been one, hung around with hundreds, and met literally thousands of em, many of them violent in the extreme.
Now, if I won't move to East Nashville because it's just too violent, that ought to tell you something.
And it's not only because of the violence perpetrated; it's who that violence is perpetrated upon - you simply don't know who might be next, although if you look like you might have a few dollars, your target potential seems to jump exponentially, and that is the main problem in my mind.
It's one thing if you're engaged in criminal activity or hangin with the creeps - you can pretty much count on eventually being burned; no honor among theives and all. But in East Nashville, all you have to do is be there, minding your own bidness, walking the dog, sitting on a bus bench, coming home from work, and you might become the victim of unspeakable violence at the hands of two-bit turds masquerading as humans.
I may spend my days working there, but I can't and wont risk my and my wife's nights. That's for damned sure.....
Newcomers determined to revitalize E. Nashville
Despite crime, they like neighborhood vibe, affordability
Todd Love's home was burglarized two years ago. A year later, a group of teens robbed him at gunpoint while he was bicycling to a corner market in his neighborhood.
Despite those encounters with crime, Love didn't rethink his safety in East Nashville until a Vanderbilt University professor and his sister were fatally shot just a few blocks away in the professor's home.
Last week, Love decided to buy a gun.
"This is my home and I don't want to be forced out of it," Love said. "But I have to defend myself."
Crime has been falling in East Nashville — including a 20 percent drop last year — but its neighborhoods have remained among the top five ZIP codes for violent crime in Davidson County since 2004, police records show. Still, newcomers to the old neighborhoods remain committed to renovation and renewal.
They drive past ramshackle drug houses and broken-down cars to the affordable Victorian homes they are restoring and the new trendy bakeries and bars dotting the landscape. Some of them shrug at the petty thefts of lawn mowers and potted plants.
But the recent murder of Pierre Colas, the Vanderbilt professor, served as a grim reminder that revitalization isn't complete.
While many have noticed improvements, others, such as Love, say crime persists beyond a comfortable level, despite the constant police patrols and myriad community meetings where neighbors search for solutions.
Rick Rider acknowledges the neighborhood has improved but he still carries a gun to work at the market he has operated on South 19th Street for the past decade.
Rider, an East Nashville native, has been robbed four times since his store opened, although nothing's happened in the past five years. That's partly because people know about his gun, and his store has bulletproof glass. But it's also because the neighborhood has gotten better, he said.
"The more people come over here and buy the houses, the more they push the crime rate out," he said.
Rider, a witness to the culture clash, spends most days in front of his store, sipping soda and greeting his varied customer base.
On a recent summer evening, a shirtless man left Rick's Market, just as a young woman in a chic pantsuit entered. Rider doesn't sell as much Bud Light these days, and instead stocks his coolers with high-dollar beers.
"You have to change with the neighborhood," he said.
He didn't know of any other gun stores in East Nashville, and he knew there would be an up-and-coming market for one in a community that was seeing an influx of upper-middle-cl ass residents.
"It was going to mean there was going to be an increase in property crime because the criminal element is still around," Bernstein said. "They see people who obviously have money, who obviously have expensive toys and who are easy targets."
Although Bernstein mostly caters to customers who already have guns, the past year has brought an increase in first-time buyers.
"People who have described themselves as being anti-gun are now seriously considering it,'' he said.
Bernstein saw a spike around the time professor Colas and his sister, Marie, were killed, which also coincided with a surge of street robberies in East Nashville.
East Precinct Cmdr. Bob Nash said a typical week brings nine robberies that usually involve drug transactions or take place in areas where lots of drug trafficking occurs. But last month, there were as many as 21 robberies in one week, and "truly innocent victims" were targeted — residents walking dogs, headed home, getting out of their cars.
Undercover officers were put in several places where the robberies were occurring most often, and neighbors were asked to help. Several arrests have been made, Nash said, and the number of personal robberies has dropped.
It was an unfortunate surge in crime that police can't explain, but Nash is confident spikes like that can be quelled. In fact, police say preliminary numbers show East Nashville crime trending downward again this year.
The increased police presence, community vigilance and revitalization have been primary reasons behind the reduction in property and violent crime in East Nashville, Nash said. Law enforcement defines violent crime as homicide, rape, robbery and aggravated assault.
"There have been pockets all over East Nashville that over the years became blighted and we are now seeing a tremendous revitalization of so many of those neighborhood people taking ownership, houses once vacant are now being refurbished with families, and that is a tremendous assistance in ridding us of the crime development," Nash said.
The criminals, he said, will be made uncomfortable to the point that they go elsewhere or they stop committing crimes.
The murders on McFerrin Avenue should not be a deterrent from continuing that progress, he said.
"For a time it's going to be a setback," Nash said. "But that's a resilient neighborhood. We have resilient people over here and there is so much progress being made that can't be ignored.''
The community, after World War II, had become a haven for rental properties and low-income families. But in the late 1970s and early 1980s, things were beginning to turn around. Low-interest loans and grants gave incentives to renovate. A historic overlay protected the look and feel of the Victorian homes and discouraged developers from razing and building stock housing. Urban renewal was becoming more popular.
"Those kinds of things were very far-reaching and I'm not sure anybody in the early days knew how far-reaching those things would be," said Allen, an agent with Village Real Estate Services.
Crime still pervaded the community, but the longtime residents were confident in their ability to turn it around.
"When I first bought my house (in East Nashville), one out of 10 people would say, 'Boy, that's really cool,' " Allen remembered. "The other nine would say, 'You've lost your mind.' "
In April 1998, a tornado ravaged East Nashville, leaving destruction and uncertainty in its wake. But adventurous souls took the insurance money and began to rebuild. Residents created a vision for what they wanted the neighborhood across the river to be, and from the rubble rose the beginnings of a vibrant community.
Allen said it wasn't long before East Nashville became a trendy yet affordable place to live.
Today, the community has attracted an eclectic group of newcomers and businesses. Residents are moving from Hendersonville and Brentwood for the urban village atmosphere that has been created there, Allen said. As prices rise in the neighborhood's core, he said, buyers looking for affordability will probably move to other sections of East Nashville, where revitalization will continue.
"You've got a $400,000 house and a crack house next door," said Love, who moved to East Nashville 13 years ago.
He had lived in communities all over Nashville, including Belle Meade and Germantown, but he came to East Nashville for its affordability, proximity to downtown, historic homes and diversity of people.
Aubrey Durnin, a part-time teacher at University School of Nashville, moved to East Nashville several months ago from Sylvan Park for the reasonable housing prices.
Expecting the crime to stop just because new people move in is unrealistic, he said. Still, she would prefer a safer neighborhood and would move if she could afford it.
But she recognizes East Nashville offers more than inexpensive housing.
"There is a really good artistic vibe going on," Durnin said. "There's a lot of new businesses and enthusiasm behind it, and a lot of people who are excited about doing something different."
Ian McCullough is one of those people.
He moved to East Nashville in 2003 after living in some of the worst neighborhoods in Chicago; Portland, Ore.; and Detroit.
He and his wife looked at crime statistics before they moved here, and saw that East Nashville had twice the crime rate of the typical American neighborhood. But it didn't scare them. Instead, McCullough saw potential.
He had seen cities across the country cashing in on the renewal of neighborhoods near the urban core, catering to people who no longer wanted the long commutes associated with the suburbs. He saw that Nashville lagged behind the trend, but knew it wouldn't be long before redevelopment reached East Nashville.
The change McCullough was banking on is in full swing now, he said, but he recognizes that progress is still a block-by-block process.
"Some people don't believe that much in East Nashville the way others do,'' Scruggs said.
She fears wealthier people have just moved in long enough to flip a house and make a profit. She doesn't see how the influx of businesses and restaurants benefits her.
"You go down the street and have to pay $7 for a hamburger. You think we can afford that?" Scruggs asked. "That's what we fuss about all the time here. We have to go to McDonald's to get something to eat because we can't afford it."
Still, Scruggs would like to see her street and surrounding neighborhood become a safer place. While the landscape has changed a few blocks away, she sees things have remained the same on her street, where
"no trespassing" signs warn passers-by, and chain-link fences surround small yards scattered with toys.
She longs for sidewalks and a time when residents were comfortable sitting on their front porches in the evening, talking to one another from house to house. She feels forgotten on this street, lost somewhere between recidivism and redevelopment.
Across the street, Melissa Woodard, 24, also worries about the improvements and what might happen if the redevelopment moves toward her. The East Nashville native moved to her Lillian Street house because it was more spacious and quieter than some other sections of East Nashville. "If they tear these houses down, what are we going to do?" she asked. "Where are we going to go? You can't help but wonder."
A single mother of three, she doesn't visit the new restaurants or shops.
"We don't associate with them," she said. "They stay to themselves, and we stay to ourselves."
East Nashville residents, regardless of their income or address, have one thing in common: They want safer streets and better living conditions, and no one wants to get pushed out in the process — not by crime or redevelopment.
Contact Rachel Stults at 615-726-8904 or rstults@tenness ean.com.
Despite those encounters with crime, Love didn't rethink his safety in East Nashville until a Vanderbilt University professor and his sister were fatally shot just a few blocks away in the professor's home.
"This is my home and I don't want to be forced out of it," Love said. "But I have to defend myself."
Crime has been falling in East Nashville — including a 20 percent drop last year — but its neighborhoods have remained among the top five ZIP codes for violent crime in Davidson County since 2004, police records show. Still, newcomers to the old neighborhoods remain committed to renovation and renewal.
They drive past ramshackle drug houses and broken-down cars to the affordable Victorian homes they are restoring and the new trendy bakeries and bars dotting the landscape. Some of them shrug at the petty thefts of lawn mowers and potted plants.
But the recent murder of Pierre Colas, the Vanderbilt professor, served as a grim reminder that revitalization isn't complete.
While many have noticed improvements, others, such as Love, say crime persists beyond a comfortable level, despite the constant police patrols and myriad community meetings where neighbors search for solutions.
Rick Rider acknowledges the neighborhood has improved but he still carries a gun to work at the market he has operated on South 19th Street for the past decade.
Rider, an East Nashville native, has been robbed four times since his store opened, although nothing's happened in the past five years. That's partly because people know about his gun, and his store has bulletproof glass. But it's also because the neighborhood has gotten better, he said.
"The more people come over here and buy the houses, the more they push the crime rate out," he said.
Rider, a witness to the culture clash, spends most days in front of his store, sipping soda and greeting his varied customer base.
On a recent summer evening, a shirtless man left Rick's Market, just as a young woman in a chic pantsuit entered. Rider doesn't sell as much Bud Light these days, and instead stocks his coolers with high-dollar beers.
"You have to change with the neighborhood," he said.
'Resilient neighborhood'
Bill Bernstein opened Eastside Gun Shop on East Trinity Lane three years ago.He didn't know of any other gun stores in East Nashville, and he knew there would be an up-and-coming market for one in a community that was seeing an influx of upper-middle-cl
"It was going to mean there was going to be an increase in property crime because the criminal element is still around," Bernstein said. "They see people who obviously have money, who obviously have expensive toys and who are easy targets."
Although Bernstein mostly caters to customers who already have guns, the past year has brought an increase in first-time buyers.
"People who have described themselves as being anti-gun are now seriously considering it,'' he said.
Bernstein saw a spike around the time professor Colas and his sister, Marie, were killed, which also coincided with a surge of street robberies in East Nashville.
East Precinct Cmdr. Bob Nash said a typical week brings nine robberies that usually involve drug transactions or take place in areas where lots of drug trafficking occurs. But last month, there were as many as 21 robberies in one week, and "truly innocent victims" were targeted — residents walking dogs, headed home, getting out of their cars.
Undercover officers were put in several places where the robberies were occurring most often, and neighbors were asked to help. Several arrests have been made, Nash said, and the number of personal robberies has dropped.
It was an unfortunate surge in crime that police can't explain, but Nash is confident spikes like that can be quelled. In fact, police say preliminary numbers show East Nashville crime trending downward again this year.
The increased police presence, community vigilance and revitalization have been primary reasons behind the reduction in property and violent crime in East Nashville, Nash said. Law enforcement defines violent crime as homicide, rape, robbery and aggravated assault.
"There have been pockets all over East Nashville that over the years became blighted and we are now seeing a tremendous revitalization of so many of those neighborhood people taking ownership, houses once vacant are now being refurbished with families, and that is a tremendous assistance in ridding us of the crime development," Nash said.
The criminals, he said, will be made uncomfortable to the point that they go elsewhere or they stop committing crimes.
The murders on McFerrin Avenue should not be a deterrent from continuing that progress, he said.
"For a time it's going to be a setback," Nash said. "But that's a resilient neighborhood. We have resilient people over here and there is so much progress being made that can't be ignored.''
Residents had a vision
Andy Allen agrees. He began his real estate career in East Nashville in 1979, when houses sold for as little as $6,400 and sales were tough to make.The community, after World War II, had become a haven for rental properties and low-income families. But in the late 1970s and early 1980s, things were beginning to turn around. Low-interest loans and grants gave incentives to renovate. A historic overlay protected the look and feel of the Victorian homes and discouraged developers from razing and building stock housing. Urban renewal was becoming more popular.
"Those kinds of things were very far-reaching and I'm not sure anybody in the early days knew how far-reaching those things would be," said Allen, an agent with Village Real Estate Services.
Crime still pervaded the community, but the longtime residents were confident in their ability to turn it around.
"When I first bought my house (in East Nashville), one out of 10 people would say, 'Boy, that's really cool,' " Allen remembered. "The other nine would say, 'You've lost your mind.' "
In April 1998, a tornado ravaged East Nashville, leaving destruction and uncertainty in its wake. But adventurous souls took the insurance money and began to rebuild. Residents created a vision for what they wanted the neighborhood across the river to be, and from the rubble rose the beginnings of a vibrant community.
Allen said it wasn't long before East Nashville became a trendy yet affordable place to live.
Today, the community has attracted an eclectic group of newcomers and businesses. Residents are moving from Hendersonville and Brentwood for the urban village atmosphere that has been created there, Allen said. As prices rise in the neighborhood's core, he said, buyers looking for affordability will probably move to other sections of East Nashville, where revitalization will continue.
Progress takes time
But the progress is patchwork, residents say, varying from block to block."You've got a $400,000 house and a crack house next door," said Love, who moved to East Nashville 13 years ago.
He had lived in communities all over Nashville, including Belle Meade and Germantown, but he came to East Nashville for its affordability, proximity to downtown, historic homes and diversity of people.
Aubrey Durnin, a part-time teacher at University School of Nashville, moved to East Nashville several months ago from Sylvan Park for the reasonable housing prices.
Expecting the crime to stop just because new people move in is unrealistic, he said. Still, she would prefer a safer neighborhood and would move if she could afford it.
But she recognizes East Nashville offers more than inexpensive housing.
"There is a really good artistic vibe going on," Durnin said. "There's a lot of new businesses and enthusiasm behind it, and a lot of people who are excited about doing something different."
Ian McCullough is one of those people.
He moved to East Nashville in 2003 after living in some of the worst neighborhoods in Chicago; Portland, Ore.; and Detroit.
He and his wife looked at crime statistics before they moved here, and saw that East Nashville had twice the crime rate of the typical American neighborhood. But it didn't scare them. Instead, McCullough saw potential.
He had seen cities across the country cashing in on the renewal of neighborhoods near the urban core, catering to people who no longer wanted the long commutes associated with the suburbs. He saw that Nashville lagged behind the trend, but knew it wouldn't be long before redevelopment reached East Nashville.
The change McCullough was banking on is in full swing now, he said, but he recognizes that progress is still a block-by-block process.
Residents share a desire
Just two blocks away from new upscale lofts and markets, longtime Lillian Street resident Levonia Scruggs, 78, doesn't think the changes will last."Some people don't believe that much in East Nashville the way others do,'' Scruggs said.
She fears wealthier people have just moved in long enough to flip a house and make a profit. She doesn't see how the influx of businesses and restaurants benefits her.
"You go down the street and have to pay $7 for a hamburger. You think we can afford that?" Scruggs asked. "That's what we fuss about all the time here. We have to go to McDonald's to get something to eat because we can't afford it."
Still, Scruggs would like to see her street and surrounding neighborhood become a safer place. While the landscape has changed a few blocks away, she sees things have remained the same on her street, where
"no trespassing" signs warn passers-by, and chain-link fences surround small yards scattered with toys.
She longs for sidewalks and a time when residents were comfortable sitting on their front porches in the evening, talking to one another from house to house. She feels forgotten on this street, lost somewhere between recidivism and redevelopment.
Across the street, Melissa Woodard, 24, also worries about the improvements and what might happen if the redevelopment moves toward her. The East Nashville native moved to her Lillian Street house because it was more spacious and quieter than some other sections of East Nashville. "If they tear these houses down, what are we going to do?" she asked. "Where are we going to go? You can't help but wonder."
A single mother of three, she doesn't visit the new restaurants or shops.
"We don't associate with them," she said. "They stay to themselves, and we stay to ourselves."
East Nashville residents, regardless of their income or address, have one thing in common: They want safer streets and better living conditions, and no one wants to get pushed out in the process — not by crime or redevelopment.
Contact Rachel Stults at 615-726-8904 or rstults@tenness

