I've spent a long time being poor, at times homeless and much of it addicted to drugs of one sort or another. I've lived this particular way from coast to coast, in the heartland, the south, the west and in the desert. In all that time, I never saw faith-based organizations as a means to my survival. Until I came to Nashville. I've been working on the street here for about 18 months and frankly, if it wasn't for the faith-based community's effort in assisting those who are poor and homeless, I don't know how they would make it. I have developed a tremendous respect and admiration for the work these groups and organizations have done and continue to do daily on our streets here. Many people owe their lives to the kindness and generosity of the many fine folks who make them up. With that said, I must add however, that if it comes to an issue that tramples the Constitution - even if it's a gentle step upon it, cloaked in the name of God - I would not approve or support it, simply because of the slippery slope it initiates..... (Wapo Editorial) A Worthy Mission The District strikes an innovative deal to serve the homeless -- but is it constitutional?"But it also raises serious questions about whether the District would be inappropriately-- and unconstitutionally -- subsidizing the mission's faith-based programs, including worship services and faith-based counseling offered at its shelters."
Monday, September 1, 2008; Page A12
TWO YEARS ago, the Central Union Mission, a nonprofit Christian social services ministry, decided to build a new homeless shelter on four parcels it owned on Georgia Avenue NW in Ward 1. Park View residents fought the move vigorously. The resistance triggered negotiations between the mission and the District that led to a novel solution.
The mission would turn over ownership of the Georgia Avenue parcels to the District, which would tear down the existing structures and build a mixed-use project that would include long-term housing for the chronically homeless. In turn, the District would give the mission title to a 12,000-square-f
The deal itself is a creative solution to what has been an intractable problem. But it also raises serious questions about whether the District would be inappropriately
The District claims that there is no subsidy. It argues that it comes out ahead on the deal because it saves $1.5 million a year for the next 40 years -- or $60 million -- by not having to operate the shelter. Even so, but for the District's largess, it's likely that the mission would not be able to afford the Gales School property on its own.
But this does not mean that the deal has to be nixed. In recent years, the Supreme Court has torn down barriers that once prevented government from giving money to religious organizations. The recipients, however, have to agree to use the funds only for non-religious purposes. The mission has a long, distinguished and honorable record of serving the District's homeless. The deal may meet constitutional muster if the mission guarantees that it provides meals and shelter without consideration of religion or participation in religious activities.
And the rebuttal.....
Have Faith in Whatever Eases Homelessness
The Sept. 1 editorial "A Worthy Mission; The District strikes an innovative deal to serve the homeless -- but is it constitutional?
Yes, the men and women served by a faith-based mission will receive sometimes mild and sometimes "over the top" preaching about Christianity.
Yes, to provide government funding of such programs could be considered a breach of the church-state conundrum.
But where do we draw the line between providing long-term rehabilitation for hurting people and restricting the kind of help they can get?
During my 12 years of experience in this area, I found myself vacillating between "Just help the people; don't try to shove Jesus down their throats," to "whatever works on a proven long-term basis." My final judgment was to opt for the latter.
We'll never "end" homelessness. The causes are myriad, including lack of low-income housing and jobs paying living wages; unresolved mental health issues; and addictions to drugs and alcohol.
Our country's first and often most effective warriors in this struggle have been the faith-based missions. Our taxes have often been spent in far less productive ways.
