6.16.2007

Why Helen at Traveler's Aid Is So Demanding Of Her Clients

(Traveler's Aid does exactly what its name implies and is a great resource for those who find themselves stranded in a large city with little or no money and want to go someplace else. The service isn't to be used for joyrides and trips of fancy, but for those with a genuine need to travel, Traveler's Aid is there to assist. The "one bad apple spoils the whole bunch" adage applies again here and our local Traveler's Aid Chief bus-ticket buyer, Ms. Helen, has heard just about every reason someone wants to go somewhere else. She's listened to some heart-wrenching tales over the years, as well as some ingenious scams, and she has learned not to make the rookie mistakes our friends in the story below made. When Helen gets a request for aid by someone, that someone had better be able to prove to Helen's satisfaction the reason for travel is legitimate.)

Homeless man's story could be tall tale

By Rochelle E.B. Gilken

Palm Beach Post Staff Writer

Saturday, June 16, 2007

This was supposed to be a heartwarming story.

With the help of a deputy and the Marine Corps League, a homeless man named James Willis got a bus ticket to spend his dying days with his long-lost brother in Greensboro, N.C. Then the story changed. Willis said his brother died in the days before he arrived by Greyhound in Greensboro.

And now, all that's left is a story.

The people who helped Willis now concede they never checked out the 55-year-old alcoholic's claims before they gave him a $121 bus ticket.

Palm Beach County Sheriff's Cpl. Karl Martin and past commandant of the Marine league, Robert McKenna, did not confirm whether Willis served in Vietnam with the Marines, whether he actually has terminal cancer in his bones, or whether he has a brother in Greensboro.

"Absolutely, I feel betrayed," said Martin. "If this situation ever came up again, yeah, I'd do a lot of research. We believed his story. We never did a confirmation. ... His story has been consistent over a year."

Now Willis is in a Greensboro homeless shelter, saying he endured a harrowing trip and wants to come back to Florida.

The gesture to help a dying man generated an outpouring of sympathy. U.S. Rep. Ron Klein, D-Boca Raton, called Martin a "hero" on the House floor Friday morning.

U.S. Rep. Alcee Hastings, D-Miramar, wrote Martin a letter commending him for the good deed.

But Willis is not much better off now than he was living in the woods.

Reached at the Greensboro Urban Ministry on Friday, he said it's cold and raining in North Carolina and he doesn't know anyone. He insists his brother died and his brother's wife moved away after he boarded the bus Wednesday. He said he lost all the addresses, phone numbers as well as proof of his illness and military service in transit.

Willis says he doesn't understand why they can't confirm his story.

"It does upset me. I don't know why they couldn't find records on me," he said.

McKenna said Wednesday he had confirmed that Willis' brother Ronnie would pick him up at the bus station through a phone conversation between the brothers.

But McKenna now says he didn't hear the man on the other end of the line.

"We should've, looking back now, me and Karl should've took Ronnie's name and phone number. We didn't think to talk to Ronnie ourselves. ... He could've been talking to a dead end. I don't know," McKenna said. "We were just trying to help a brother Marine out. Our job isn't to investigate every inch and angle."

McKenna said he doesn't think it was an intentional scam and that Willis is confused after years of alcohol abuse. McKenna maintained on Friday that he believes Willis, a felon with 25 arrests in Florida, is a dying veteran.

McKenna said Willis knew too much about the veterans hospital and Marine units to be making it up.

Martin had said he empathized with Willis' experience in the Marines. He now says they never sat and talked about it. He said the only check he did was to run Willis' name for outstanding warrants. And he said he never heard Willis on the phone with his brother.

But he said it didn't matter whether Willis had a brother or served in the Marines or suffered from cancer. He would've helped any sick homeless man in the woods who asked for it.

"If he asks for help again I probably wouldn't help him. He took advantage of a good thing," Martin said.

It is unclear how long Willis will stay at the shelter. The sheriff's office said he has refused to stay in shelters in the past because he wants to continue drinking.

Willis said he doesn't want to stay where he is because they only take people in for two months - even though he says he won't live that long. He said he's going to try to find someone who will send him back to Florida.

"If I have to go to a truck stop and try to catch a ride back, I can't stay here. I ain't got nothing here. I ain't got that much time left," Willis said.

Smiling does a body good

Democracy Now Livestream