Ah, the Downtown Park. Beautiful, isn't it? It's a shame this tiny piece of public space located in the heart of the business district of downtown Nashville is the cause of so much controversy and consternation amongst so many in our fine city.
But mired in controversy and consternation it is, and the reason for this centers upon how best to address the Homeless population that also seems to many to congregate there as if they were drawn by a powerful mystical force known only to them.
But the reason it's so attractive to the Homeless is really no mystery. In fact, it's actually quite obvious and simple, if one pays attention to the needs of the Homeless, and the park meets those needs better than any other place in Nashville at the moment.
First, the park is centrally located in the heart of downtown and it's easy to get to by those both new into town and for those who need a midpoint stop as they travel for services from the west end of Nashville to the east end - and vice versa. This is what happens when you scatter very scarce and very important services far apart from each other. For instance, the Community Care Fellowship (CCF) is located over on 8th street off of Shelby. It's the only place where laundry can be done for free and it is one of only two places that showers can be taken as well. Guess where the other showers are? That's right - over on the west side. Unfortunately, CCF typically closes down by mid afternoon most days and is closed on the weekends, so those folks who hang there all morning are then forced to disperse elsewhere.
I'm too new to Nashville to know much about the period here when services were more centralized, but I've been told by people on both sides of the privatization debate that the problems with transient populations downtown escalated severely soon after those services were privatized and dispersed. Unfortunately, this is one of those all too common detrimental "unknowns" that can occur when privatization and resultant fragmentation of services occurs.
My point here isn't to stir debate about the merits or problems with privatization per se, I'm only trying to point out that at some point, services catering to the Homeless and indigent became much more fragmented and dispersed across Nashville, causing significant travel demands on a population least equipped to travel city streets. The park is very conveniently located to services in all directions and makes a fine resting place for those who must criss-cross the town as they chase these scarce resources.
Second, the park is located next to about the only temperature-controlled building that allows unfettered access to the public - the downtown library. The library also has a couple of other things that make it a very important structure. It has one of only two available bathrooms in the downtown area that allow Homeless people access with little or no scrutiny and/or regulation. When the library closes in the afternoon the one other bathroom is the only option and it is a considerable hike for those who feel an urgent call of nature. And trust me, when one has been eating the diet of the Homeless for a long time, occasionally one needs a bathroom in the worst sort of way, and one needs it immediately.
The library is also the only place where one can access both newspapers and computers. There are many Homeless who use these things for a myriad of reasons, but especially to hunt for jobs, believe it or not.
Third, the park is close to certain stores that cater to those with lower incomes and have certain items that are attractive to people with.....weaknesses - especially alcohol. Did you know that over at the Dollar General store just a couple of blocks away, you can pick up a big bottle of mouthwash that is essentially 80-proof alcohol, and it's available at the bargain price of $1.90? That's right, a buck ninety for a quart of highly intoxicating mouthwash, and you don't even have to be 18, let alone 21, to purchase it. The better-behaved park regulars call these folks "the wash drinkers" and they'll be the first to tell you that this particular subset of park aficionados causes the vast majority of problems due to their belligerence, their drunken outbursts, and their distasteful habit of public "pottying" whenever and wherever the urge strikes them.
But it's not just alcohol. Many Homeless folks who frequent the park do almost their entire shopping solely at the Dollar General store because of the great prices on merchandise usable by them that is found there. Please understand, I'm not laying blame for the Homeless problems at Dollar General's doorstep but am merely enlightening those who cannot understand what it is that so attracts the Homeless to the downtown park.
Believe it when I say here that there are many law-abiding Homeless who patronize the park and realize how badly a "few bad apples" are spoiling their own right to occupy this public space. Unfortunately, it is very very dangerous for one Homeless person to castigate or interfere with another Homeless person's illegal and/or asinine activity. Doing so may get you ostracized and since we've pretty much already ostracized them from regular society, this is something they simply cannot afford to have happen. it may also get them beaten, robbed or even killed by the individual they snitched "intervened" on.
I believe there may a misconception by some in the downtown business community that because some agencies and groups serve food and/or otherwise deliver donated goods and services to the Homeless congregating in the park, this perpetuates the return of the Homeless to this area and increases the population at the location as a result. While there is a kernel of truth in this, the issue is a bit more complex.
The groups serving the Homeless are typically underfunded and overburdened. They seek out the Homeless in the largest concentrations to maximize their own meager resources' coverage and effectiveness (Mobile Loaves & Fishes new food-serving truck is helping to alleviate this situation somewhat). That the population in the park is always substantial makes it an ideal - and a natural - place to go. These groups are simply responding to a very dire need in the best way they know how, and they are doing so on a wing, prayer and shoestring. Sending them packing for caring for the downtrodden is a very bad public relations debacle, make no mistake about it.
And frankly, chasing off those who stop to assist the Homeless in this area does very little to discourage them from continuing to congregate in the park. It does however serve to inflame tensions among the charitable groups and the business community, anger the Homeless and their advocates, create animosity between those charged with keeping our streets and city clean and safe and those who feel that their right to occupy public spaces shall not be infringed, and generally makes the situation much uglier and difficult to correct than it need be.
If you want the Homeless to leave the park, I suspect the quickest, most equitable and most humane way would be to provide them with a suitable alternative.
Now that we are at least somewhat aware of the problems and criteria that impact the Homeless and make the park such an attractive location. I wonder if there is a way we can all work together to find (or create???) a place that might be better suited for them than the downtown park? Rest assured, virtually no solution will bring immediate change at this location but with some patience and some real commitment to making it happen, I believe it's possible to bring a very pleasant resolution to this situation.
“And homeless near a thousand homes I stood, and near a thousand tables pined and wanted food” ~Wordsworth
6.20.2007
Some Thoughts On The Downtown Park....
Ah, the Downtown Park. Beautiful, isn't it? It's a shame this tiny piece of public space located in the heart of the business district of downtown Nashville is the cause of so much controversy and consternation amongst so many in our fine city.
But mired in controversy and consternation it is, and the reason for this centers upon how best to address the Homeless population that also seems to many to congregate there as if they were drawn by a powerful mystical force known only to them.
But the reason it's so attractive to the Homeless is really no mystery. In fact, it's actually quite obvious and simple, if one pays attention to the needs of the Homeless, and the park meets those needs better than any other place in Nashville at the moment.
First, the park is centrally located in the heart of downtown and it's easy to get to by those both new into town and for those who need a midpoint stop as they travel for services from the west end of Nashville to the east end - and vice versa. This is what happens when you scatter very scarce and very important services far apart from each other. For instance, the Community Care Fellowship (CCF) is located over on 8th street off of Shelby. It's the only place where laundry can be done for free and it is one of only two places that showers can be taken as well. Guess where the other showers are? That's right - over on the west side. Unfortunately, CCF typically closes down by mid afternoon most days and is closed on the weekends, so those folks who hang there all morning are then forced to disperse elsewhere.
I'm too new to Nashville to know much about the period here when services were more centralized, but I've been told by people on both sides of the privatization debate that the problems with transient populations downtown escalated severely soon after those services were privatized and dispersed. Unfortunately, this is one of those all too common detrimental "unknowns" that can occur when privatization and resultant fragmentation of services occurs.
My point here isn't to stir debate about the merits or problems with privatization per se, I'm only trying to point out that at some point, services catering to the Homeless and indigent became much more fragmented and dispersed across Nashville, causing significant travel demands on a population least equipped to travel city streets. The park is very conveniently located to services in all directions and makes a fine resting place for those who must criss-cross the town as they chase these scarce resources.
Second, the park is located next to about the only temperature-controlled building that allows unfettered access to the public - the downtown library. The library also has a couple of other things that make it a very important structure. It has one of only two available bathrooms in the downtown area that allow Homeless people access with little or no scrutiny and/or regulation. When the library closes in the afternoon the one other bathroom is the only option and it is a considerable hike for those who feel an urgent call of nature. And trust me, when one has been eating the diet of the Homeless for a long time, occasionally one needs a bathroom in the worst sort of way, and one needs it immediately.
The library is also the only place where one can access both newspapers and computers. There are many Homeless who use these things for a myriad of reasons, but especially to hunt for jobs, believe it or not.
Third, the park is close to certain stores that cater to those with lower incomes and have certain items that are attractive to people with.....weaknesses - especially alcohol. Did you know that over at the Dollar General store just a couple of blocks away, you can pick up a big bottle of mouthwash that is essentially 80-proof alcohol, and it's available at the bargain price of $1.90? That's right, a buck ninety for a quart of highly intoxicating mouthwash, and you don't even have to be 18, let alone 21, to purchase it. The better-behaved park regulars call these folks "the wash drinkers" and they'll be the first to tell you that this particular subset of park aficionados causes the vast majority of problems due to their belligerence, their drunken outbursts, and their distasteful habit of public "pottying" whenever and wherever the urge strikes them.
But it's not just alcohol. Many Homeless folks who frequent the park do almost their entire shopping solely at the Dollar General store because of the great prices on merchandise usable by them that is found there. Please understand, I'm not laying blame for the Homeless problems at Dollar General's doorstep but am merely enlightening those who cannot understand what it is that so attracts the Homeless to the downtown park.
Believe it when I say here that there are many law-abiding Homeless who patronize the park and realize how badly a "few bad apples" are spoiling their own right to occupy this public space. Unfortunately, it is very very dangerous for one Homeless person to castigate or interfere with another Homeless person's illegal and/or asinine activity. Doing so may get you ostracized and since we've pretty much already ostracized them from regular society, this is something they simply cannot afford to have happen. it may also get them beaten, robbed or even killed by the individual they snitched "intervened" on.
I believe there may a misconception by some in the downtown business community that because some agencies and groups serve food and/or otherwise deliver donated goods and services to the Homeless congregating in the park, this perpetuates the return of the Homeless to this area and increases the population at the location as a result. While there is a kernel of truth in this, the issue is a bit more complex.
The groups serving the Homeless are typically underfunded and overburdened. They seek out the Homeless in the largest concentrations to maximize their own meager resources' coverage and effectiveness (Mobile Loaves & Fishes new food-serving truck is helping to alleviate this situation somewhat). That the population in the park is always substantial makes it an ideal - and a natural - place to go. These groups are simply responding to a very dire need in the best way they know how, and they are doing so on a wing, prayer and shoestring. Sending them packing for caring for the downtrodden is a very bad public relations debacle, make no mistake about it.
And frankly, chasing off those who stop to assist the Homeless in this area does very little to discourage them from continuing to congregate in the park. It does however serve to inflame tensions among the charitable groups and the business community, anger the Homeless and their advocates, create animosity between those charged with keeping our streets and city clean and safe and those who feel that their right to occupy public spaces shall not be infringed, and generally makes the situation much uglier and difficult to correct than it need be.
If you want the Homeless to leave the park, I suspect the quickest, most equitable and most humane way would be to provide them with a suitable alternative.
Now that we are at least somewhat aware of the problems and criteria that impact the Homeless and make the park such an attractive location. I wonder if there is a way we can all work together to find (or create???) a place that might be better suited for them than the downtown park? Rest assured, virtually no solution will bring immediate change at this location but with some patience and some real commitment to making it happen, I believe it's possible to bring a very pleasant resolution to this situation.
Democracy Now Livestream
democracynow on livestream.com. Broadcast Live Free
Important Homelessness, Poverty, Hunger & Research Links
- AFLCIO
- Action Against Hunger
- Aids Housing Of Washington
- Alliance for Retired Americans
- America's Second Harvest
- American Association of Homes and Services for the Aging
- American Bar Association Commission on Homelessness and Poverty
- American Civil Liberties Union
- American Enterprise Institute
- American Public Human Services Division
- American Rhetoric
- Amnesty International
- Annenberg Public Policy Center
- B Love Foundation
- Bazelton Center Mental Health Law
- Beyond Shelter
- Big Issue Magazine
- BigThink
- Boise ID Interfaith Sanctuary (Shelter for the body, food for the soul)
- Bread for the World
- Brookings Institute
- Bureau of Economic Research
- Bureau of Justice
- Bureau of Primary Health
- CARE
- Campaign for Home Energy Assistance
- Campus For Human Development
- Carnegie Endowment
- Carter Center
- Cato Institute
- Center For Corporate Policy
- Center For Global Development
- Center for American Progress
- Center for Budget & Policy Priorities
- Center for Law & Social Policy
- Center for Urban Community Services
- Center on Hunger and Poverty
- Chicago Coalition For The Homeless
- Child Welfare League
- Child Welfare League of America, Housing & Homelessness Initiative
- Chrysalis
- Citizens Circle For Accountability
- City Mayors Society
- Civil Rights org
- Co-Occurring and Homeless Activities Branch
- Coalition on Human Needs
- Commission on Homelessness & Poverty
- Common Ground
- Commonwealth Fund
- Communities United Against Police Brutality
- Community Action Partnership
- Community Connections
- Community Foundation: Nashville Temporary Housing Research
- Contact Congress
- Congressional Hunger Center
- Consumer Federation of American Center for Housing and Credit Policy
- Corporation for Supportive Housing
- Council for Affordable and Rural Housing
- Crisis
- Cross Cultural Solutions
- CyberSchoolBus
- Department of Health and Human Services
- Directory of Local Homeless Service Organizations
- ENPHRONT (Everywhere and Now Public Housing Residents Organizing Nationally)
- EPath: People Assisting The Homeless
- Economic Policy Institute
- Emergency Food & Shelter National Board Program
- Endgame: Research Links A to Z
- Enough
- Enterprise
- Ethics Updates
- FAIR
- FactCheck org
- Federal Statisitcs
- FindLaw
- First8
- Food Research & Action Center
- Food Stamp Program
- FoodFirst
- Freedom From Hunger
- Galaxy Star
- Georgia Law Center for the Homeless
- Give Us Your Poor
- Global Communications Network For Justice
- Government Accountability Office
- GrassRoots.org
- Growing Home
- Growing Home
- Habitat for Humanity
- Hands on Nashville
- Harvard Kennedy School
- Health & Human Services
- Health Care for the Homeless Information Resource Center
- Healthcare for the Homeless
- Help USA
- Heritage Foundation
- HomeBase
- Homeless Nation.org
- Homeless Policy Academies
- Homeless Veteran Reintegration Program Fact Sheet
- Homeless Women's Network
- Homeless World
- Homeless.org
- Homelessness Resource Center
- Housing America
- Housing Assistance Council
- Housing First
- Housing Research Foundation
- Human Rights Watch
- Hunger & Homelessness Survey 2005
- Hunger, Homelessness & Poverty Task Force
- HungerWeb.org
- Institute For Peace & Justice
- Institute for Sustainable Communities
- Institute for the Study of Homelessness and Poverty
- Institute of Health Promotion Research
- Institute of Law, Psychiatry & Public Policy
- Institute on Religion & Public Policy
- Interaction
- Interagency Council on Homelessness
- International Food Policy Research Institute
- International Hepatitis Foundation
- Joint Center For Poverty Research
- Joint Center for Political & Economic Studies
- Journal of Poverty
- Justice Research & Statisitcs Association
- Justice Talking
- Kaiser Family Foundation
- Kensington Welfare Rights Union
- Librarians Internet Resource
- Lindesmith Center - Drugs Policy Foundation
- Los Angeles Homeless Coalition
- MIT OpenCourseWare
- Mad Housers
- Mad Philosophers
- Mamma's Hands
- McKinney-Vento Act
- Meals on Wheels of America
- Middle Tennessee Methadone Treatment Center
- Motivational Interviewing
- Narcotics Anonymous
- Nashville Homeless Power Project
- Nashville Peace & Justice Center
- National AIDS Housing Coalition
- National Affordable Housing Management Association
- National Alliance for the Mentally Ill
- National Alliance of HUD Tenants
- National Alliance to End Homelessness
- National American Indian Housing Council
- National Center for Family Homelessness
- National Center for Homeless Education
- National Center for Homeless Education at SERVE
- National Center for Trauma-Informed Care
- National Clearinghouse on Families & Youth
- National Coalition for Homeless Veterans
- National Coalition for the Homeless
- National Congress for Community Economic Development
- National Employment Law Project
- National Fair Housing
- National Health Care For The Homeless Council
- National Housing Conference
- National Housing Law Project
- National Interfaith Hospitality Network
- National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty
- National Low Income Housing Coalition
- National Network for Youth
- National Policy and Advocacy Council on Homelessness
- National Poverty Center
- National Resource Center on Homelessness and Mental Illness
- National Student Campaign Against Hunger & Homelessness
- Neighborhood Reinvestment Corporation
- New England Journal of Medicine
- Non Profit Roundtable
- NonViolence org
- OMBWatch
- Office of Management and Budget
- OxFam
- PATH
- Partnership For Prescription Assistance
- Partnership For The Homeless
- Partnership to End Long Term Homelessness
- People's Economic Human Rights Campaign
- Picture The Homeless
- Poverty USA
- Poverty and Policy
- Poverty and Race Research Action Council
- Poverty topic page of the Development Gateway
- Project Hello
- Project VoteSmart
- Public Agenda
- Public Eye org
- Public/Private Ventures
- RAND
- Rasumussen Reports
- Results
- SAMHSA Homelessness Resource Center
- SecularWeb
- Securities & Exchange Commission
- Shelter Partnership Inc
- Shriver Center National Center on Poverty Law
- Sistering
- SourceWatch
- Southern Alliance For Animal Welfare: Love Your Pet - Fix your Pet
- Southern Poverty Law Center
- Street Connect
- Street Law
- Sustainable Cities
- Technical Assistance Collaborative
- The Doe Fund
- The Many Faces Of Poverty and Homelessness
- Tolerance.org
- Traveler's Aid International
- Treatment Accountability For Safer Communities
- USA.Gov
- United For a Fair Economy
- United Way Nashville
- United Way of America
- University of Michigan Poverty & Social Welfare Policy
- Urban Justice Center
- Vera Institute of Justice
- Veterans For Common Sense
- Veterans For Common Sense
- Volunteers of America
- VoteVets.org
- Washington Grantmakers Daily
- Weingart Center Homeless Research Catalog
- Wellbriety For Prisons
- WiseEarth
- Working Psychology
- Yale University - Institution for Social & Policy Studies
- ute for Children & Poverty
