11.02.2011

Allowing "The Vent" Might Just Be The Greatest Service Providers Can Offer Those With Lived Experience

I recently reached out to a gentleman I worked with heavily while a Veteran Services Coordinator at Operation Stand Down Nashville, Inc. in order to try and solicit the man's top three ideas/suggestions for how we (service providers in general) could have made his experience better as he navigated the system.

A little background: "George" suffered from several physical and mental health challenges, including a Bipolar disorder and some anger management issues. He was also a larger man who occasionally sported a large and "natural" (untrimmed and scraggly) beard that added to the overall impression of  disorganized "wildness," for lack of a better phrase. When he spoke about his situations - and there were a number of situations that were causing him severe distress - he was clearly re-traumatizing himself  in the process, and as this occurred, it ramped up his level of intensity in his speech and actions. 

His gaze would become very penetrating and intense.  His face would flush and he would tremble as he expressed himself.  He often paced, and vigorously used his arms and hands to add emphasis to his points.  In short, he appeared on the brink of losing control and lashing out physically, and because he was big, sort of wild looking with that gnarly ol beard, and his face would get bright red while his eyes burned into you with the intensity of lasers, the guy invoked a visceral fear in people, especially people who may have viewed themselves as totally unable to defend themselves if this guy ever cut loose.  I suspect too that because he was a veteran who had been trained in the art of combat and warfare, it added to the fear factor for providers as well.

So poor George would believe he was getting the opportunity to finally tell his story to someone who was supposed to help him and he would get passionate and animated in the process. Because so much had happened to him, it was hard for him to put it into a coherent and chronological order, as most long-term situations are, and he wanted to make sure that he was able to get it all out to the person because in order to understand his predicament you needed to understand the big picture.

This caused him to "race" through his conversation, which caused him to appear "agitated." As he recalled some of the more serious injustices he believed were perpetrated against him, he became retraumatized, which made him angry, which then amplified his gestures and caused him to fidget and begin turning red in the face.

At about this point, most providers would become alarmed and begin fearing for their personal safety. It may not have been an overt action, but trust me, they would be making some pretty quick assumptions and drawing conclusions based on what they were seeing physically, and as this was happening, it became harder for them to listen to what he was saying, since the mind of the provider had entered the "fight or flight" autonomic response pattern and was gearing up itself for the possibility of a coming conflict.

Now George wasn't really being listened to, he was being assessed/judged on his physical actions, and the provider was all but shut down on the "providing" part while figuring out how to get this man out of their office with as minimal threat to themselves and others as possible.

In this fashion, I suspect George had been handed off to a good many folks, and every time this happened, George had to repeat the whole process of explaining himself, which led to retaumatization and an increasing anger over the fact that those who were supposed to help him didn't seem to give two turds about actually doing so.  In George's mind, this had to be because he wasn't presenting his story clearly enough, which then caused him to try and get even more of it out in that introductory conversation, which set the whole cycle in motion again but with more intensity than the time before, and time before that, and time before that, etc. etc. etc.

George's situation with providers may be one of the more extreme versions of this phenomenon, but I can tell you that it isn't a rare one.  I often wonder if, had we given people more time to first vent and just listen to them as they shared whatever it was they wanted to share, we would have found a much more amicable and "compliant" (God I just HATE that word) person on the other side of the desk.

  Part of our problem as a person with lived experience out there is that no one listens when WE speak.  There are many reasons for this, but one thing I think providers should understand is that by the time that provider actually has a face to face with someone experiencing homelessness, mental health challenges and/or substance use conditions (and the way I've "labeled" these things is done with deliberate attention to the impact labels have on us all) that person has had so many barriers, challenges, abuses and "disses" chalked up in their past that it's almost impossible for them to lay out their story in a comprehensive and calm manner that can be easily understood. 

Hence, the provider see's a "wild-eyed, ticked off, 'non-compliant and anxious' individual who appears to ramble and be unfocused."

Additionally, As we tell our story and in the process retraumatize ourselves from the discourse, we tend to get...a bit passionate about the injustices we've suffered.  This of course adds to the impression we're leaving on the provider, who often just sees as "angry."

Well, I got news for ya: Hell YES we're angry, and rightfully so, given the sometimes unconscionably terrible treatment we've received at the hands of providers, police, businesses, community members and family members.

The key I think for providers here is to understand that the anger isn't typically JUST about them.  It's the culmination of years, sometimes decades, of anger fulminating out of us and onto their shoulders because we finally have someone to listen to us and we want to be damned sure we try to tell them everything so they can really understand.

I believe that if providers could just realize - especially during those first couple of meetings - that the trauma experienced over our lifetime is flowing out through that initial venting session and allow us to get beyond it to the point where we are able to calm down enough to be impressionable to solutions and help, they'd do us all a great service and may just find a wonderful, "committed to recovery" person sitting across from them. 

It's a shame that so many of us don't get that chance.  Trust me when I tell you that when this happens to you and then happens repeatedly to you, many simply stop trying to explain it to providers who "just don't get it."

Smiling does a body good

Democracy Now Livestream