10.04.2010


Measuring  pain  in the context  of homelessness


Rebecca Matter, Susan Kline,  Karon  F. Cook, Dagmar  Amtmann


Accepted: 22 June 2009 / Published online: 7 July 2009
  Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
Abstract
Purpose     The  primary  objective  of  this  study  was  to inform the development of measures of pain impact appropriate for all respondents, including homeless indi- viduals, so that they can be used in clinical research and practice. The secondary objective was to increase under- standing about the unique experience of homeless people with pain.
Methods   Seventeen  homeless  individuals  with  chronic health conditions (often associated with pain) participated in cognitive interviews to test the functioning of 56 pain measurement items and provided information about their experience living with and accessing treatment for pain. Results           The most common problems identified with items were  that  they  lacked  clarity  or  were  irrelevant  in  the context of homelessness. Items that were unclear, irrele- vant and/or had other identified problems made it difficult for  participants  to  respond.  Participants  also  described multiple  ways  in  which  their  pain  was  exacerbated  by


R. Matter (&)
Center for Technology and Disability Studies, University
of Washington, Box 357920, Seattle, WA 98195-7920, USA

S. Kline
Public Health—Seattle and King County, 2124 Fourth Avenue, Seattle, WA 98121, USA

K. F. Cook   D. Amtmann
Department of Rehabilitation, University of Washington, Box 357920, Seattle, WA 98195-7920, USA
K. F. Cook

D. Amtmann

conditions of homelessness and identified barriers to accessing appropriate treatment.
Conclusions    Results suggested that the majority of items were problematic for the homeless and require  substantial modifications to make the pain impact bank relevant to this population.  Additional recommendations  include  involving homeless in future item bank development, conducting research on the topic of pain and homelessness, and using cognitive interviewing in other types of health disparities research.

Introduction

Homeless people disproportionately suffer from health problems, many of which are associated with acute or chronic pain (e.g., tooth decay, arthritis), and frequently these health problems go untreated due to substantial bar- riers to receiving appropriate care [1–3]. Common health problems identified among the homeless include diabetes, cancer, anemia, hypertension, asthma, heart disease, peripheral vascular disease, dental problems, neurological disorders, musculoskeletal problems (i.e., arthritis), ulcer, depression, amputation, or other disabilities [4–6]. In addi- tion, untreated injuries and infections can become chronic conditions  [3].  Health  problems are  exacerbated  by  the conditions of homelessness such as lack of a comfortable sleeping place, exposure to weather, prevalence of violence, inadequate health and hygiene practices, overcrowding at shelters, unreliable food sources, and extensive walking [4].

One  of  the  barriers  homeless  individuals  encounter when  seeking  appropriate  health  care  is  lack  of  health insurance or  inadequate  coverage [7].  According to  the 2005 census, 14.3% of the U.S. population lacked health insurance. Greater than 50% of homeless persons are without health  insurance; most who have  insurance are covered by Medicaid, Medicare, or Veterans Affairs insurance [8]. Other barriers to receiving appropriate health care include inability to pay, lack of transportation, frag- mented and discontinuous care options, discriminatory treatment of homeless people by health care professionals, and mistrust and fear of health care professionals [9, 10]. High rates of mental health and substance abuse problems [11, 12], and low literacy levels [13, 14] create additional health care barriers [15].  It is estimated that 2.3–3.5 million people experience homelessness each year in the United States, and this is expected to increase by another 1.5 million over the next 2 years due to the recession [16]. Data from 2007 report that at a point in time 22/10,000 individuals in the United States, 36/10,000 in Washington State, and 42/10,000 in King County (the study location) are homeless[17].

Pain and homelessness
Pain is an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with actual or potential tissue damage, or described  in  terms  of  such  damage  [18].  While  it  is known that homeless individuals experience more chronic health problems (many of which are associated with pain) than domiciled individuals, pain prevalence among homeless persons is not known. In fact, there is very little research on homelessness and pain.  A  literature review conducted via PubMed, CINAHL, and PsychInfo using keywords ‘homeless,’ ‘homelessness,’ and ‘pain’ (limited to abstracts/titles) in the past 10 years identified no arti- cles  that  addressed  pain  as  the  primary  topic.  The  24 articles in which pain  was a secondary topic  addressed issues such as homelessness and health service utilization, end-of-life  care,  oral  health,  substance  abuse,  and  dis- eases and conditions such as HIV/AIDS and hepatitis C [19–23]. Data collected in 2006 by the Seattle Health Care for the Homeless Network estimated the local prevalence of acute or chronic pain at 24% for patients seeking health care at shelters, transitional housing programs, or homeless-spe- cific clinics [24]. Pain complaints were associated with oral health status, musculoskeletal conditions, and specific symptoms such as headache, abdominal discomfort, chest pain, dysuria, dysmenorrhea, and pain in general.

Pain measurement

It is generally accepted in the research community that the experience of pain is subjective, and therefore the most
meaningful approach to measuring pain is self-report. As noted by ‘‘The Initiative on Methods, Measurement and Pain Assessment in Clinical Trials,’’ patient-reported out- comes are ‘‘particularly important for conditions that involve symptoms such as pain and fatigue’’ [25]. Numerous pain instruments are currently used by researchers and clinicians to assess pain, but we found no study that included the homeless in the validation samples. The same was true for other underserved populations. Two studies were found that evaluated the validity of health surveys (Short-Form 36, Short-Form 12) in a sample of homeless persons, but both surveys assess overall health status and do not focus on pain [26, 27].

Purpose

This  study  was  conducted  under  the  umbrella  of  the patient-reported outcomes measurement information sys- tem (PROMIS) initiative that is developing dynamic and validated measures for the measurement of self-reported outcomes. PROMIS is one of the National Institute of Health (NIH) Road-map initiatives. The NIH is committed to addressing health disparities across all NIH institutes and centers and has identified increased representation of undeserved populations in clinical research as a goal of this  comprehensive  effort  [28,  29].  This  study,  that involves an underrepresented population, is part of a larger PROMIS research project aimed at validating pain measurement items. 

The purpose of this study was to (1) ensure that item banks for measuring interference of pain, that were generated by the larger PROMIS research project, are suitable for homeless individuals and can be used in clin- ical research and practice and (2) increase understanding among  health  care  providers,  researchers,  and  policy makers about the unique experience of homeless people with pain, specifically their experience seeking treatment for pain. Scale developers, typically work at academic institution,  have  advanced  educational  levels  and  come from upper middle class background and therefore may have difficulties reflecting the experiences of the under- privileged in their work. This often results in scales that are appropriate for middle class respondents with experiences similar to those of scale developers. To lessen this bias, PROMIS  investigators  conducted  extensive  interviews with individuals experiencing pain from a broad range of socioeconomic and ethnic backgrounds. However, due to the difficulties involving homeless people in research, only one participant in the PROMIS cognitive interviews was homeless. Based on the feedback from this participant who found  many items irrelevant  to  his experience  and had difficulties answering questions about how pain impacts his functioning, investigators decided to conduct an additional study focused solely on the homeless.  
 
Study sample
A convenience sample of homeless individuals was recruited  through posting flyers at  Seattle  area  shelters, transitional  housing  programs,  and  public  agencies.  In order to recruit a sample as diverse as possible, flyers were posted at organizations that targeted their services to spe- cific subpopulations (e.g., women, men age 50 and older, homeless people with health problems). Study inclusion criteria were (1) 18 years or older, (2) diagnosed with a disability or chronic health condition typically associated with pain, and (3) spent most of the past 3 months in non- permanent  living  options.  Demographics  and  primary health conditions were collected from participants as well as self-reported average levels of pain, fatigue, and diffi- culty with physical function over the past 7 days.

Study design
Face-to-face cognitive interviews were conducted to gather data for this study. The primary purpose of the cognitive interviewing process was to explore how homeless indi- viduals thought about and experienced pain and learn about cognitive processes they used when responding to ques- tions about pain interfering in their lives. Cognitive inter- viewing is frequently used to identify problems (e.g., irrelevant items) with questionnaires by examining the cognitive processes that participants use to answer ques- tions [30–32]. Research protocols developed by PROMIS for cognitive interviews were modified and implemented for this study. The protocol for the pain banks can be found on the website at http://www.nihpromis.org/Web%20Pa ges/Bank%20Construction.aspx.

Interviews  lasted  between  45 min  and  2 h  and  took place  in  a  private  meeting  room  at  the  Seattle  Central Public Library in downtown Seattle. Interviews were lead by a primary interviewer. An additional research staff member  attended the  interviews and took detailed  field notes. All interviews were audio recorded to corroborate and complete field notes as needed.

Before beginning the interview, each participant com- pleted a consent form, demographic form, and the wide range achievement test (WRAT3) [33]. The WRAT3 has been  used  as  a  quick  assessment  of  literacy  level  in research studies [34]. Reading level was assessed because the ability of respondents to understand the questions is essential  for  validation  of  paper-and-pencil  instruments. The  interview  and  subsequent  analyses  were  structured into two parts: (1) pain measurement and (2) pain experience.

Pain measurement
Fifty-six pain items that were included in the PROMIS preliminary pain impact bank were selected to be tested within the homeless population to ensure relevance. These items were selected because they targeted measurement of the impact of pain on the lives and lifestyles of participants. In addition, nine ‘global’ items that asked about overall health and quality of life were included in the study, such as ‘‘In general, would you say your quality of life is’’ with response  options  ‘‘Excellent,  Very  good,  Good,  Fair, Poor.’’ Six pain intensity items that measured worst, average, least, and current pain were also administered, for a total of 72 items. All 72 items were developed and tested as part of the PROMIS [35]. We decided to test the pain items in the homeless group because of prevalence of pain in this population and lack of existing research.

All of the pain impact items followed the same format of item context, item stem, response scale.  For example, a standardized item  read  as follows: ‘‘In the  past 7 days, overall how much did pain interfere with your daily activities? Not at all, A little bit, Somewhat, Quite a bit, Very much.’’ The item context is the time frame: ‘‘In the past 7 days,’’ the item stem is ‘‘overall how much did pain interfere with your daily activities,’’ and the response scale is ‘‘Not at all, A little bit, Somewhat, Quite a bit, Very much.’’

The 72 items were divided into 4 sets of 18 items each, and each set was administered to three to five participants. Each participant was asked to respond to the set of can- didate items in paper-and-pencil format ‘‘as if you were filling out the form at a doctor’s office.’’ After the partic- ipant completed the set of items, the primary interviewer used a list of questions and follow-up probes to encourage the participant to verbalize his or her thought process in answering the items. The questions and probes addressed four main areas: item clarity, timeframe, item content, and response  format. To gauge item clarity,  the  interviewer asked whether the question was clear to the participant. For timeframe, participants were asked what timeframe they considered when responding to the questions. We used the 7-day timeframe in this study because of the PROMIS pain banks used this timeframe in the testing. Questions regarding item content focused on participants’ under- standings of the item and challenges encountered in answering the item. Participants were asked, ‘‘Was this question easy or hard to answer’’ and ‘‘What comes to mind when you think about this question.’’ For the final topic, response format, participants were asked, ‘‘Were the response options appropriate? Were there too many or too few options?’’ Participants were also asked for suggestions about how to improve each of the items. 

To analyze  the  data,  we used a  modified version of the   questionnaire   appraisal   system   (QAS)   [36]   as described   in   Table 1.   In   preparation   for   analysis, researchers summarized field notes for each of the four sets of pain measurement items into one single text document. Audio recordings were referenced  as  needed to supplement field notes. For coding purposes, the first two categories within the QAS (Problems with Reading the  Question  and  Problems  with  Instructions)  and  the Open-Ended  Question  subcategory  were  excluded  from the coding scheme, because they did not apply. The remaining five categories and 20 subcategories were used for coding.

Two coders trained in the modified-QAS system, inde- pendently coded each of the four sets. Coders reviewed the summaries of feedback for each set of 18 items, and an item was coded as having a specific QAS problem if the problem was identified as such by at least one of the three to five participants. Disagreements between the two coders were resolved by consensus. Coders were encouraged to identify additional item problems that were not captured by the QAS.

Pain experience
After  providing  feedback  about  each  item,  respondents were invited to provide additional information about their experience living with and managing pain. At the end of the interview, they were asked, ‘‘Have you sought treat- ment for your pain?’’ If they responded ‘‘Yes,’’ they were requested to describe their experience seeking treatment for pain. These qualitative data were organized into main themes and summarized. This study was approved by the University of Washington’s Institutional Review Board and informed consent was obtained from all participants.

Results

Sample characteristics

Tables 2 and 3 display participant  demographic charac- teristics.  The  mean  age  of  participants  was  50.5 years (range = 39–75). The majority of participants were male (77%), from racial groups other than white (59%), were




Table  1  QAS coding definitions

Categories                                             Definition

1. Clarity                                               Identify problems related to communicating the intent or meaning of the question to the respondent
1a. Wording                                          Question is lengthy, awkward, ungrammatical, or contains complicated syntax
1b. Technical terms                              Terms are undefined, unclear, or complex
1c. Vague                                             There are multiple ways to interpret the question or to decide what is to be included or excluded
1d. Reference periods                          Time periods are missing, not well specified, or problematic
2. Assumptions                                    Determine whether there are problems with assumptions made or the underlying logic of the question
2a. Inappropriate assumptions             Belief or idea in question is inaccurate regarding the respondent or his/her situation
2b. Assumes constant behavior            Question fails to account for situations when behaviors or experiences vary
2c. Double-barreled                              Contains more than one implicit question
3. Knowledge/memory                         Check whether respondents are likely to not know or have trouble remembering information
3a. Knowledge                                      Respondent is unlikely to know the answer to a factual question
3b. Attitude                                          Respondent is unlikely to have formed the attitude being asked about
3c. Recall                                              Respondent may not remember the information asked for
3d. Computation                                   The question requires a difficult mental calculation
4. Sensitivity/bias                                 Assess questions for sensitive nature or wording, and for bias
4a. Sensitive content                             The question asks about a topic that is embarrassing, very private, or that involves illegal behavior
4b. Sensitive wording                           Given that the general topic is sensitive, the wording should be improved to minimize sensitivity
4c. Socially acceptable                         A socially acceptable response is implied by the question
5. Response categories                          Assess the adequacy of the range of responses to be recorded
5a. Mismatch                                        There is a mismatch between question and response categories
5b. Technical terms                              Terms are undefined, unclear, or complex
5c. Vague                                             Response categories are subject to multiple interpretations
5d. Overlapping                                    Response categories are overlapping
5e. Missing                                           Eligible responses are missing in response categories
5f. Illogical order                                 Response categories are in an illogical order




Table  2  Participant characteristics (N = 17). Mean age 50.5, range
39–75

N

Gender
Female                                                                                        4
Male                                                                                         13
Race/ethnicity
White                                                                                          7
Black or African–American                                                       2

least  one  night  over  the  past  3 months,  the  two  most common responses were ‘shelter/transitional housing/tent city’  (77%)  and  ‘public  parks/streets/under  a  bridge’ (35%).

The most frequently reported health condition was arthritis (47%). Other chronic health conditions reported by participants included back pain, diabetes, multiple sclero- sis, AIDS, and lupus. Nearly half of the participants (47%) reported their average level of pain and fatigue over the past 7 days as severe or very severe, while the remainder




































American Indian/Alaska native
1
(53%) reported mild or moderate pain and fatigue. While
Hispanic
3
substance abuse and mental health status questions were
Multi-racial
4
not  systematically  asked,  many  participants  volunteered
Relationship status                                                                                   information, indicating they  had substance abuse (36%)
Never married
6
and mental health (29%) issues. Other health characteris-
Married
3
tics are presented in Table 4.
Separated/divorced
8

Highest grade level

Pain impact items
Some high school
3

High school grade/GED
3
Coders  using  the  modified-QAS coding  method  agreed
Some college/technical degree/AA
9
between 91.2 and 96.9% of the time, with Cohen’s kappa
College degree
2
ranging from 0.61 to 0.82 indicating substantial agreement
Employment status                                                                                   [37].  Table 5  displays  problems  identified  with  the  56
Unemployed
9
impact items. QAS categories that had no identified prob-
Retired
1
lems  were  removed  from  Table 5.  The  analysis  of  the
Disabled
6
remaining 15 pain intensity and global items was limited
Full-time student
Annual income
1
by the small number of items tested, and thus were not
included in results.
Less than $20,000
17
Based on the QAS coding system, four problems were
Veteran
3
identified in at least 20% of the tested pain impact items.
Places stayed for at least one night in the past three months

These  were  issues  related  to  lack  of  clarity  regarding
Vehicle
2
timeframe referenced when responding to items, vagueness
Shelter/transitional housing/tent city
13
of item content, inappropriate assumptions made by items,
Public park/streets/under a bridge
6
and vagueness of item response categories.
Friend’s/relative’s home
2

Motel/hotel
3
Table  4  Health characteristics
Other (own apt)
1
N

 
Indicated substance abuse issue                                                     6
Indicated mental health issue                                                          5


Table  3  Reading level (WRAT3)—grade level

N

Post-high school                                                                            10
High school                                                                                     4
Eighth grade                                                                                    2
Sixth grade                                                                                      1

unemployed or disabled (88%), and reported some post- high school education (65%). The WRAT3 test identified
58.8% with a  post-high school education  reading  level.

When asked to identify places where they stayed for at


Chronic health condition or disability
Arthritis/osteoarthritis/joint disease                                                8
Back pain                                                                                       4
Other musculoskeletal (e.g., scoliosis)                                           4
Diabetes                                                                                          4
AIDS/HIV                                                                                       2
Multiple sclerosis                                                                           1
Lupus                                                                                             1

Pain     Fatigue      Physical function difficulty

Mild
2
1
3
Moderate
7
8
4
Severe/very severe
8
8
10


 
In the past 7 days, average level of pain (N)




Table  5  Problems with pain impact items

QAS categories
Subcategories
N
%
1. Clarity
1a. Wording
1
2

1c. Vague
32
55

1d. Reference periods
43
75
2. Assumptions
2a. Inappropriate assumptions
18
32

2b. Assumes constant behavior
1
2

2c. Double-barreled
2
4
3. Knowledge/memory
3d. Computation
1
2
4. Sensitivity/bias
4a. Sensitive content
2
4
5. Response categories
5a. Mismatch
7
13

5c. Vague
11
20

5d. Overlapping
2
4

5e. Missing
6
11

5f. Illogical order
3
5


Items that were unclear, irrelevant and/or had other identified problems  made  it  difficult for  participants  to respond with certainty and accuracy. Table 6 presents the common issues that participants experienced when responding  to  items  and  provides  specific examples  of words and phrases that were problematic or a description of the problem.

Difficulties with accuracy
In addition to the common problems identified through the QAS coding, participants had difficulty in honing in on the specifics of what some items were asking. For example, when asked ‘How much did pain make it difficult to fall asleep?’  one  participant  responded  about  his  ability  to sleep, not focusing specifically on falling asleep. Another recurrent issue was the difficulty participants had in iso- lating the impact of pain as a contributor to an outcome. For example, when asked ‘How often did pain make you feel depressed?’ one participant proceeded to tell stories about his multiple sources of depression such as lack of money, dealing with the threat of physical violence when living on the streets, and physical pain and was not able to consider only the impact of his pain on depression. Other examples of confounding factors include the impact of medication or uncomfortable sleeping conditions and pain on ability to sleep.

Ways of responding to problematic items
When participants responded to items identified as vague or having inappropriate assumptions, they typically responded in one of four ways: (1) left item blank, (2) selected ‘Not At All’ to signify that the item ‘Does Not Apply’ since there was no ‘Does Not Apply’ option, (3) modified the specific meaning of words/phrases in the item to better reflect their life  circumstances  (e.g.,  when  a  participant  was  asked, ‘How much did pain interfere with doing your tasks away from home,’ he  identified the  shelter  as  his  home  and described his tasks away from home as going to the library and church), (4) selected a  meaning for items  that  had multiple interpretations (e.g., ‘family life’ means nuclear family), or (5) selected the middle answer as a ‘‘safe option.’’ For example, in reference to an item about pain’s impact on household chores, one participant stated, ‘‘It is not relevant to me. I do not have household chores to do at this time but selected ‘somewhat’ just to answer question.’’

Pain experience in the context of homelessness

To increase understanding among health care providers, researchers, and policy makers about the unique experience of homeless people with pain, we collected and summa- rized participants’ experiences living with, managing, and seeking  treatment  for  pain.  The  results  are  reported  in Table 7.
These results describe how conditions of homelessness exacerbate suffering caused by pain and create barriers to pain management and treatment. Participants clearly rec- ognized that their experience living with pain would be improved if they were not homeless. As one participants expressed, ‘‘If I had a home, I would be able to soak in a hot tub to relieve some of this, and sleep in a comfortable bed I could take care of myself better—but I’m not. I have to stand to take a shower and lay on a matt on the floor with all kind of women around me. It’s totally different when you have pain and have a home, or don’t have a home.’’
The majority of participants expressed dissatisfaction, and some expressed extreme frustration with their experi- ences seeking and receiving treatment for pain. They reported numerous examples of inappropriate and poor quality care, specifically not receiving proper assessments of pain or only being offered ibuprofen instead of more effective  longer-term  treatment  regimens. Consequently, many participants found other ways to deal with pain such as learning to tolerate the pain and self-medicating with legal or illegal substances. Only a few participants reported being able to access quality care, because they had insur- ance through the VA or located a health care provider at a community clinic.

Discussion

Measuring pain
Cognitive  interviewing  was  found  to  be  an  effective method for testing items and yielded useful information. 
Table  6  Types of item problems

Types of problems                                                  Examples/description

Vague (unclear meaning)                                         • ‘day to day activities’
• ‘social activities and relationships’
• ‘emotionally tense’
• ‘discouraged’
Vague (multiple interpretations)                              • ‘close personal relationships’ = romantic relationships or friends and family
• ‘family life’ = nuclear family or extended family
• ‘long distances’ = down the hallway or 2 miles
• ‘fatigue’ = tired or depressed
• ‘interference’ = prevented from engaging or engaging made more difficult

Inappropriate assumptions (irrelevant to life circumstances in multiple domains)

• Social: ‘recreational activities,’ ‘leisure activities’
• Relationships: ‘family life,’ ‘close personal relationships’
• Domestic: ‘work around home,’ ‘tasks away from home’
• Employment: ‘work,’ ‘ability to work’

Lack of adherence to 7-day timeframe                   • Referring to shorter or longer timeframes
• Referring to salient event [36] such as a life changing event (e.g., becoming homeless, loosing job, having an accident) instead of the 7-day timeframe
Vague response options                                          • Subjective terms: ‘poor,’ ‘fair,’ ‘somewhat’


Table  7  Pain experience

Living with and managing pain
• Poor weather conditions increase pain level, specifically for participants with arthritis
• Poor sleeping conditions exacerbate suffering caused by pain such as sleeping on streets, in shelters, or in vehicles
• Grogginess caused by pain medications is a challenging side effect because of lack of safety living on streets (‘I need to keep my wits about me to protect myself’)
• Self-medicating with marijuana or other illegal substances to alleviate pain and promote a restless sleep
• Lack of treatment options result in homeless people developing a high tolerance for pain (‘I guess you get used to it’)
• Health problems, many associated with pain, begin with or are intensified by homelessness (‘Most people I know did not have pain before they came to the shelter, at the shelter they come down with a lot of stuff.’)
• Participants fear of becoming addicted to pain medication (i.e., methadone, morphine)
Accessing quality treatment
• Lack of health insurance and primary care provider contributes to high use of urgent care centers
• It can take many months to locate and get an appointment with a health care provider who will accept medical coupons (‘Doctors are overloaded’)
• Discriminatory and poor treatment of homeless by health care providers and staff at local urgent care centers due to status of clients (i.e., homeless, poor physical appearance, and lack of insurance). Participants stated that they were not taken seriously, not trusted, not listened to, and not provided a proper diagnosis (‘‘… being homeless, doctors don’t care. If I had job and a place, insurance—they would be going out of their way to take care of me’’)
• Assumption on behalf of health care providers that all homeless are drug-seeking (‘‘…if you are homeless they automatically think you are a drug addict’’)
• Common treatment at local urgent care centers is to provide ibuprofen
• Health care providers’ liability and concern of overmedicating or contributing to drug-seeking behaviors inhibits proper treatment (‘‘Doctors are constrained to give out meds because they might get in trouble’’)



Data  analyses suggest that  substantial modifications are required to make pain impact items clear and relevant to the  experience of  pain  in  the  homeless population.  For development of future pain item banks, we recommend that developers examine, modify, and test terminology used in items  and  response  categories  to  increase  clarity  and
address inappropriate assumptions. Researchers and clini- cians should also be aware of the tendency for individuals to disregard the 7-day timeframe.
It is notable that item stems that were identified as being ‘vague’ or having ‘inappropriate assumptions’ often were those associated with a domiciled and typical life such as
having relationships, a family, a home, a job, comfortable sleeping conditions, and the ability to participate in leisure/ recreational activities. Items pertaining to socializing and relationships were challenging for participants to answer because they had a very small or no social network of friends, family, and/or co-workers; and because they did not engage in normal social activities such as going out to a restaurant or movie. As one participant stated, ‘‘I did not become homeless until I was 50…There are two Seattles I know of. There is the Seattle that gets up and goes to work every day, watches TV, goes on vacations; and there is the homeless side where there is treachery, thievery, and BO….They sleep on mats, it’s horrible. You don’t cultivate relationships.’’
Some of our findings parallel to those obtained in research with domiciled populations, suggesting that some item problems are not unique to the homeless population. Specifically, retrospective reporting is difficult and partic- ularly complicated when those reports are related to pain [38]. In addition, the term ‘interfere’ was found to be problematic in other research on pain items [39].

Pain experience

Physical pain is challenging to address even in populations with stable homes and employment, health insurance, and access to quality health care. The physical discomforts and stressors of homelessness exacerbate suffering caused by pain, create multiple obstacles to pain management, and barriers to  accessing quality  treatment.  The majority  of study participants had sought treatment from the same local urgent care center and expressed dissatisfaction and frustration with the health care received. While the high level of use at this urgent care center can be partially attributed to location, the over-utilization of urgent care centers by homeless has been thoroughly documented in previous research [40, 41].

Recommendations

The following recommendations described in Table 8 aim to improve pain items and reduce health disparities in research and clinical practice that impact homeless individuals.

Best practices: conducting research with the homeless

The lack of consideration by researchers for participants other than those with typical middle class living arrangements reflects that these populations are more difficult for researchers to reach, recruit, and retain. As found in recent health disparities research, overcoming recruitment barriers is critical to addressing health disparities [42]. Here, we provide best practices in conducting research with homeless individuals and other diverse populations.

We  found  that  a  discussion  with  key  individuals  at agencies that serve homeless persons was very helpful in establishing trust and identifying the most appropriate mechanisms  for  recruitment.  Procedures  and  personnel vary from place to place, and persons who know the institution  or  agency  and  the  persons  served  can  best advise what strategies are likely to be successful. Also, because of the lack of predictable structure in the lives of persons who are homeless, it is important not to schedule interviews too far in advance. The further from the initial contact date the interviews are scheduled, the less likely the participant will be to make the scheduled interview. Similarly, it is important upon initial contact with a participant to identify multiple ways to reach the participant (phone number at shelter, leaving message with a friend) if participant fails to show up. In our study, we did not encounter  any  situations that  presented a  danger to  the interviewers, but it was important that the safety of interviewers be considered and addressed. We implemented a safety plan for safely exiting the interview and getting help if the participant arrived inebriated or became hostile. Finally, it is critical that the interviewer remain flexible in his or her approach to the interview in order to address the diversities of issues that challenge participants who are homeless. Participants may have low levels of literacy and/or distrust of health professionals (including researchers). On the other hand, they may want to share personal stories and have difficulty attending to the interviewers’ questions. Substance abuse issues, cultural differences, and mental health issues may insinuate themselves on the interview process. All of these potential issues underscore the need for creativity and flexibility on the part of the interviewer.

Limitations
A number of limitations should be noted. First, the small sample size (N = 17) limits the generalizability of findings, especially considering the diversity of the homeless population.  Second, some  participants were reluctant  to critique the items. For example, when asked for suggestions  as  to  how  to  improve a  question, one  participant responded, ‘you guys are way smarter about wording stuff than me.’ Finally, participants received a $25 honorarium for completing the interview, and this incentive may have attracted some participants who did not legitimately meet study inclusion criteria. In response to this concern, researchers conducting interviews probed for sufficient detail about their experience of pain. In addition, participants were carefully screened and turned away when they reported  finding  out  about  the  study  through  a  friend instead of the posted flyer, and/or were unable to identify their chronic health condition.
 
Table  8  Recommendations

Researchers
• Examine, modify, and test terminology used in items and response categories to increase clarity, and address inappropriate assumptions by rewording terms to be more inclusive of diverse life circumstances (e.g., change ‘home’ to ‘where you are living’)
• Employ cognitive interviewing to identify item problems and ensure item clarity, relevance, and overall functionality
• Conduct future research on the topic of pain and homelessness to determine pain prevalence, characteristics of pain (i.e., associated prevalent health conditions), and complexities of pain that are unique to homeless individuals
• Include persons who are homeless in instrument development and validation studies as well as other clinical research to ensure study outcomes will be relevant and applicable to their atypical life conditions
Health care providers
• Administer valid standardized pain assessment measures in clinical practice to help determine legitimacy or intensity of a homeless individual’s pain
• Develop and employ clinical guidelines that address health care provider concerns regarding prescribing pain medication to individuals with or potentially with substance abuse problems
• Employ guidelines and establish institutional policies to ensure homeless persons are treated in a non-discriminatory manner by health care staff and professionals
Advocates and policy makers
• Increase awareness among health care professionals and advocates that serve homeless clients about the unique experience of pain among homeless population
• Develop community health care services that target homeless individuals suffering from chronic pain


Conclusions

The homeless population experiences a high prevalence and severity level of physical pain that is complicated by conditions of homelessness and lack of access to appropriate care. This topic has received inadequate attention both in clinical research and practice standards, and thus this underserved population is excluded from the benefits these efforts might yield. This study suggested that including homeless people in clinical research (i.e., pain measurement tool validation) is not only feasible, but it also  yields  useful results.  By  making  item  banks  more appropriate for homeless populations, clinical research and subsequent clinical policies and practices will be more relevant and useful to this population.
While this study focuses on the homeless population, the recruitment approach and research methods employed may be applicable to other diverse populations that are typically excluded  from clinical  research and over-represented in clinical practice. Health disparities research shows that we, institutional decision-makers, do not understand the unique needs or experience of underserved subgroups [43]. Cognitive interviewing may be an effective method in bridging this knowledge gap.

Acknowledgments     This research project was supported by National Institutes of Health through the NIH Roadmap for Medical Research (Grant 5U01AR052171-03). Authors would like to express gratitude to the support provided throughout the study by Health Care for the

Homeless Network, Public Health—Seattle & King County, and for help with recruitment provided by Seattle area shelters and homeless services programs. We also thank  Mark Harniss, Ph.D. for article review and the research  team for support with data collection and analysis, which included Kara Bogusz, Rana Salem, Leyla Khastou, Joe Skala, Erin Boespflug, Silvia Christian, and Selene Wu.


References

1.  Wright, J. (1990). Poor people, poor health: The health status of homeless. Journal of Social Issues, 46, 49–64.
2.  Gelberg, L., & Linn, L. (1989). Assessing the physical health of homeless adults. JAMA, 262(14), 1973–1979.
3.  Pain Management: Reducing Disparities for  Homeless  Patients.
(2004, October). Healing hands. Health Care for the  Homeless Clinicians’  Network,  National  Health  Care  for  the  Homeless Council.  Copy  Editor,  8,  1–6.  http://www.nhchc.org/Network/ HealingHands/2004/Oct2004HealingHands.pdf.  Accessed 5 Jan
2009.
4.  National Health Care for the Homeless Council.  (2002). A pre- liminary review of literature. Chronic medical illness and homeless individuals.  Nashville,   TN: Zerger S. http://www.nhchc.org/ Publications/literaturereview_chronicillness.pdf.  Accessed 5 Jan
2009.
5.  National Health Care for the Homeless Council. (2007). Home- lessness  and  health.  Policy  statements. http://www.nhchc.org/ Advocacy/PolicyPapers/HomelessnessHealth2007.pdf.  Accessed
5 Jan 2009.
6.  Savage, C. L., Lindsell, C. J., Gillespie, G. L., Dempsey, A., Lee, R. J., & Corbin, A. (2006). Health care needs of homeless adults at a nurse-managed clinic. Journal of Community Health Nursing,
23(4), 225–234.
7.  Kushel, M. B., Vittinghoff, E., & Haas, J. S.  (2001). Factors associated with the health care  utilization of homeless persons. JAMA, 285(2), 200–206.
8.  DeNavas-Walt, C., Bernadette, P. D., & Cheryl, L.  H. (2006).
Income, poverty, and health insurance coverage in the US: 2005. US Census Bureau, Current Population  Reports, P60-231, US



Smiling does a body good

Democracy Now Livestream