"The $41,000 spent on Gale's arrests is more than twice what Seattle spends, per client, on a special program that provides permanent housing and support services for some of the city's most acute (and cost-intensive)Florida understands the problems, but will lawmakers and officials do what's necessary to correct them? That, my friends, is the money question - for all of us....homeless alcoholics."
For the estimated $41,000 that Sarasota taxpayers spent on Jeffrey Gale's 45 arrests -- most of them "open container" and camping violations -- they got very little in return.
Taxpayers' "investment" whisked Gale off the streets for the few weeks he spent in jail. But it did nothing to stabilize his life; it simply let him ride the unhappy merry-go-round between homelessness and incarceration.
Spending so much to accomplish so little is bad policy and poor use of public dollars.
The $41,000 figure comes from Herald-Tribune reporter Todd Ruger's analysis, which concluded that for each nuisance-type arrest, taxpayers spent about $925 on the various legal costs involved.
For comparison, consider this: The $41,000 spent on Gale's arrests is more than twice what Seattle spends, per client, on a special program that provides permanent housing and support services for some of the city's most acute (and cost-intensive)
It's unclear whether Sarasota's municipal arrestees fit the kind of profile used in Seattle's "Housing First" program. But Seattle's $15,000-$20,000
To be sure, Sarasota can't ignore trespassing, curbside drinking and other behaviors that damage the quality of life for all. When these issues stem from people who are mentally ill or addicted, going easy on them isn't humane; it's neglectful. But when repeated arrests cost so much and do so little to address the root of the problem, it's time to rethink the strategy.
A good place to start would be to focus on the "frequent flyers," busted over and over on minor city charges. According to information from Wayne Applebee, criminal justice policy coordinator for Sarasota County Health & Human Services, there were 561 jail admissions for municipal offenses last year. Just 50 people, however, accounted for half or more of those arrests. Thirty-nine each were sent to jail three or four times on municipal offenses; 10 went five to seven times; and one person was admitted 17 times. That's for just one year. (Gale's 45 offenses accrued over a number of years.)
Statistically, we know little about nuisance violators beyond their propensity to trespass and drink on the curb. Are they homeless, jobless? Probably, police say, but why? How long? Do they have disabilities and mental health problems, as many chronically homeless do? Police say these are often people who refuse to join sobriety programs, but what kind of outreach has been done? What would it take to get them to accept treatment?
These questions need answers if we are ever to find solutions.
Talk to city police and they'll say that the local Salvation Army shelter never turns away a person who is willing to abide by its rules and, if necessary, enroll in treatment programs. But they also acknowledge that the Sarasota community needs more treatment beds and more transitional housing (as well as affordable units, in general) for those who graduate from the programs.
There won't be money for those necessities if we keep spending it on round-trip tickets to jail.
There are alternatives, such as drug court or mental health court, that are now in use for other offenders. Encouragingly, legal officials are exploring whether the same approach might help with the lesser -- but still expensive -- nuisance crimes.
Currently, drug court is set up to help felony offenders get off the drugs/prison seesaw. Instead of going to lock-up, participants commit to therapy and education; they must show up regularly before judges and pass periodic drug tests.
Screening defendants for mental disorders also makes sense. Generally, most of the persistent substance abusers have mental-health issues, said Dr. Kenneth Nutter, vice president of adult services at Coastal Behavioral Health Care. If prosecutors agree, the offender could get court-monitored
Most experts acknowledge that not all offenders accept this kind of help. Some cannot make themselves take the hard steps necessary to win back their lives. In Seattle's "Housing First" program, however, social workers were surprised to find that the most chronic offenders became willing participants.
Community leaders should be urgently pursuing these possibilities, which can be not only more compassionate but more effective -- and less expensive -- than repeated incarceration. When it comes to dealing with chronic homelessness, Sarasota should aim for being dubbed the smartest, not the meanest, city.
HEALTH AND THE HOMELESS
In heraldtribune.c
Do you agree or disagree?
Post your comments at: http://forums.h
